| Alderson Broaddus University | 325 | +41 | t-12th |
| Allegheny College | 309 | +25 | t-9th |
| California University of PA | 314 | +30 | 11th |
| Charleston University | 297 | +13 | 2nd |
| Clarion University | 325 | +41 | t-12th |
| Daemen College | 309 | +25 | t-9th |
| Gannon University | 300 | +16 | 4th |
| Billy Colbert | 73 | +2 | t-4th |
| Matt Barto | 75 | +4 | t-15th |
| Ethan Bennett | 76 | +5 | t-24th |
| Mark Majewski | 76 | +5 | t-24th |
| Emmett Caskey | 77 | +6 | t-32nd |
| Jacob Mertz# | 80 | +9 | t-56th |
| Michael Marsico# | 82 | +11 | t-63rd |
| Jordan Henry# | 83 | +12 | t-68th |
| Indiana University of PA | 307 | +23 | t-7th |
| Le Moyne College | 299 | +15 | 3rd |
| Millersville University | 296 | +12 | 1st |
| Pitt-Johnstown | 328 | +44 | 14th |
| West Chester University | 302 | +18 | 5th |
| West Liberty University | 303 | +19 | 6th |
| West Virginia State | 402 | +118 | 15th |
| West Virginia Wesleyan | 307 | +23 | t-7th |
# Indicates individual player